Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Johnny's Pizza New Oxford
Welcome to Johnny's Pizza New Oxford, a hidden gem nestled at 6115 York Rd, unit 6, in New Oxford, Pennsylvania. This delightful eatery is more than just a pizza joint; it's a community hub where great food meets genuine hospitality. With a phone call away at +1 717-688-7250, you're just moments from enjoying a meal that promises to ignite your taste buds.
Step inside, and the warmth of the staff envelops you like a comforting embrace. Customers rave about the welcoming atmosphere, and it's clear why. From the moment you enter, you're treated like family. As Kevin Mejia shared, "We immediately felt their welcome," and it's a sentiment echoed by many who have dined here.
The real star of the show is, of course, the food. The pepperoni pizza has earned rave reviews for its incredible flavor, proving that sometimes, simple is best. But don’t overlook their cheesesteak, which Kevin describes as anything but ordinary. The method of preparation seems to be a closely-guarded secret, but the resulting dish is a symphony of flavors that’s hard to forget. It's no wonder Kevin and his companions found themselves returning just two days later, ready to make Johnny’s a regular stop on their culinary journey.
But what's a great meal without great community? Patrick Rutledge's experience paints a picture of not only good eats but also good people. His lunchtime visit turned into a memorable experience when the staff lent a hand to help someone in need, demonstrating character that extends beyond the kitchen.
Every dish shines at Johnny's, whether it’s the perfectly crispy wings, the satisfying subs, or the fresh salads. And as Billie Miller pointed out, the lunch special prices make it an attractive option for anyone looking to enjoy quality food without breaking the bank.
For those adventurous enough to try new flavors, Dylan Wisser recommends the cowboy steak, a standout that showcases the culinary creativity present in this establishment. You’ve got to experience it for yourself to understand the rave reviews.
In conclusion, Johnny's Pizza New Oxford is more than just a meal; it's an experience filled with warmth, flavor, and community spirit. The combination of delicious food, friendly service, and affordability makes it a must-visit for anyone in the New Oxford area. So next time you’re driving down York Rd, make sure to swing by and discover what all the excitement is about!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Didn’t know what to expect. We immediately felt their welcome. Their pepperoni pizza was amazing! Don’t get me started on their cheesesteak it was not normal cheesesteak the way they cook that steak is their secret. So good we stopped by two days later, and have every intention of becoming regulars. Now, if youll excuse me, as seen in the photos I have some food to finish. ”
“ Came in for lunch got a great pilly cheese steak. While I was there someone's car wouldn't start and they took the time to jump their battery and get them going. Great food and good people. ”
“ Super Friendly staff! Everything is delicious from the wings & subs to pizza & salads. Amazing lunch special prices also ”
“ These guys are great! haven't had a bad experience yet. The food is reallyyy good!I've had their pizzas and subs! currently my favorite is the cowboy steak. ”
“ Right off the road, if your not paying attention you will miss them. The prices are great and the food is good. I wish you they better options for the cheese steak like mushrooms. ”
“ Amazing food,and service is always welcoming! Pizza is always packed with flavor no matter what toppings/style you prefer. Garlic Knotts are by far the best in the area! Highly recommend stopping in and getting a meal from Johnny's! ”
“ I am from Maryland visiting friends to help move for the weekend and like trying new places. So I decided to try this place out. And let me tell you. This place is delicious!!!! I got the cheese pizza, mafia pizza, chicken parm pizza, BBQ chicken pizza, cheese steak sub, and bacon ranch fries. Everything was amazing! However, the star of the show was the BBQ chicken pizza. It is soooo amazingly good. It blew everything out of the water. Like I said, everything was delicious. But my favorite was the BBQ chicken. The cheese steak was good. Your standard sub. Plenty of meat. I would like to have been able to give more of a review of the fries, but I looked away for a minute, and my son ate all of it. He said it was delicious, though. Though my friends are moving from the area, I will be making a nice little side trip to eat here again next time I am in PA. ”
“ Nice little hidden gem. I always drove past this on 94. The shopping center looks old, never really looked at any of the shops. Then, one day, I wanted pizza and noticed there was a pizza place there. The inside looks very nice. Like a diner. It's small but mighty. I guess a lot of people order to go. We were there, and maybe 10 people came in for pick up. Delicious pizza. Picture perfect. You order at the counter. Paper plates and such. ”